I had a moderately serious boyfriend toward the end of high school/beginning of college, and sometimes I really wish we’d just stayed together, because I know he didn’t want to break up, and he tried to get back together with me at one point (although I was sort of clueless about it at the time).
I want kids and my own space close to my parents (who need help with care for medical reasons) without having to live with them (my life goals are so low right now), and both of those things would be far more realistic if I’d stayed with him. I’d probably already have them.
But I also remember how severely mentally ill I’d been for years and years – it was already not great when I was with him, and it had a lot to do with why we broke up (I just couldn’t handle his demands on my attention when I was spiralling down) and here’s the thing:
I need to remember that when I was spiralling out of control and deeper and deeper into mental illness, I felt judged by him, not supported. So no, staying with him would not have fixed me or gotten me to a point where I was happy.
On a surface level, there are things about the idea of staying with him that make it seem like life would be so much better and easier. I think he genuinely loved the person I could be when I was healthy and happy and could try to act sexually interested in him.
I also think that a lot of that “health and happiness” was an act that I couldn’t sustain. I think that I was (and continue to be) very uncertain of my feelings about my own relationship to gender and sexuality and jumping into the female role in a heterosexual relationship looked like it made a lot of sense, but never felt comfortable or right to me. I think he was dismissive when I tried to explain my pain as I struggled with my mental health, and that would not have made him a good partner while I tried to get well.
What I wish I had was a good partner who was supportive (and continues to be supportive) while I try to figure out what recovery looks like. I want children and having a cis-male partner would make that easier, so I idealize his potential as a father. I’m lonely, so I assume that if I had a partner, the relationship would fill that void, even though I remember being so incredibly lonely while we were dating. I can’t even imagine telling him that I’ve been struggling with the idea of being non-binary since before we started dating. I never discussed my profound ambivalence about sex with him.
I want a lot of things that relationship could have been in theory, and things that it looked like it was from the outside, but I don’t want the relationship we actually had.
I just needed to write that out because I stumbled across his profile on social media today, and any time he pops back into my consciousness, I wonder what it would have been like to stay with him, and I need to remind myself that I already know it wouldn’t have been a good idea.